Reviews of Recent Independent, Foreign, & Documentary Films
in Theaters and DVD/Home Video
Directed by: Gregor Jordan.
Produced by: Rainer Grupe & Ariane Moody.
Written by: Jordan, Eric Axel Weiss & Nora MacCoby, based on the book by Robert O'Connor.
Director of Photography: Oliver Stapleton.
Edited by: Lee Smith.
Music by: David Holmes.
Released by: Miramax.
Country of Origin: UK/USA/Germany. 95 min. Rated: R.
With: Joaquin Phoenix, Ed Harris, Scott Glenn & Anna Paquin.
This blazingly irreverent comedy hits its machismo targets over and over again to the
point of overkill. It audaciously depicts a military made up of stoned felons and high
school dropouts, along with the odd psychopathic officer. Stationed at an U.S. Army base
in 1989 West Germany where thereís nothing to kill but the time, Ray Elwood (Phoenix)
has his fingers in many pies. The smartest man on the block, a dubious distinction,
Elwood runs a black market and heroin manufacturing factory in league with his fellow
soldiers and the military police until the arrival of Sergeant Robert Lee (Glenn). Glenn, in
a high-energy performance, leaves no doubt of whom is more determined. In stealing the
film, you canít help but root for him when he challenges Elwood, who dates Leeís
daughter Robyn (Paquin) in retaliation. How much one is repelled by the antics in
Buffalo Soldiers depends on how charmed you are by Elwood. In just one of
many misanthropic moments, Elwood clumsily applies a tiny Band-Aid on the bloodied
and bruised face of his nerdy roommate who has taken the fall for him. Smirking and
manipulating, Elwood comes across as self-righteous as Alan Aldaís Hawkeye Pierce.
Smug and entitled, he isnít compelling enough for a feature-length film, though waiting
for him to fall off his pedestal is. Suffice to say the ending is a disappointment. Kent Turner
July 27, 2003
Archive of Previous Reviews
Thompson Street, New York, NY 10012 - Contact